PDA

View Full Version : Scary Saudi Justice System



Gerry Clinchy
08-21-2010, 05:36 PM
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/38799106/ns/world_news-mideastn_africa/



Human rights group say trials in Saudi Arabia fall far below international standards. They usually take place behind closed doors and without adequate legal representation.


The victims can ask that the perpetrator suffer the same injury that has been inflicted. An eye for an eye, etc.



Those who are sentenced to death are often not informed of the progress of legal proceedings against them or of the date of execution until the morning on which they are taken out and beheaded.




According to Amnesty, in 2005, a convict in the kingdom had his teeth pulled out by a dentist because he had smashed another man's teeth out in a fight.

"We have also had cases of people sentenced to blindness because they have caused the blindness of another person," Chirouf said. "But never anything involving a spinal cord."


In the case discussed in the article, the Islamic judge is asking if the perpetrator can be paralyzed ... since that was the injury inflicted on the victim. His previous sentence had been 14 mos in jail, released after 7 mos in an amnesty. Evidently, the victim still has the ability to ask for a harsher sentence.

Nor_Cal_Angler
08-21-2010, 06:12 PM
There are those times, I wish we had a "similar" system of justice....

THOU SHALT NOT KILL......

not....if thou shall kill, thou shall live on average for another 20 years in a cell...

I also feel that a pound of flesh will be extracted for other situations....ie...you make a comment about me, my father, my brother...ohhh kay...I will and can and have walked away...but you mess up and make a comment about my mother....You AZZ is mine, and I'm GONNA (and have) slap the taste out of your mouth....

believe me...a COMMENT is all it takes!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

NCA
Ps..we arn't talking about internet forum comments either....I got big shoulders, I can take a joke.

Gerry Clinchy
08-21-2010, 07:09 PM
There are those times, I wish we had a "similar" system of justice....

THOU SHALT NOT KILL......


But it would still be nice to have a trial that is not behind closed doors.

Nor_Cal_Angler
08-21-2010, 08:28 PM
But it would still be nice to have a trial that is not behind closed doors.

VERY TRUE...I do agree there.

Get it out in the open...

ie.."a jury of your peers has found you guilt of Murder in the 1st degree, you will be murdered/exacuted in a similar fashion...you now have 24hrs to get your last rights of business together, MAY GOD HAVE MERCY ON YOUR SOUL."


NCA

dnf777
08-21-2010, 08:38 PM
In theory I have no problem with such punishment.......I just don't trust the Nifongs of the justice system to fairly and justly administer it! Can you imagine being wrongly accused and hearing the judge is shopping for doctors to surgically section your spinal cord??

Nor_Cal_Angler
08-21-2010, 10:13 PM
In theory I have no problem with such punishment.......I just don't trust the Nifongs of the justice system to fairly and justly administer it! Can you imagine being wrongly accused and hearing the judge is shopping for doctors to surgically section your spinal cord??

In theory then....you dont have the spine for it....:rolleyes::rolleyes:

Good people are usually NEVER EVER NEVER even remotely near a situation that would require that swift form of justice....

If your toes are near enough to the fire to get burnt, then you were TOOOOO CLOSE....

dnf777
08-22-2010, 06:45 AM
In theory then....you dont have the spine for it....:rolleyes::rolleyes:

Good people are usually NEVER EVER NEVER even remotely near a situation that would require that swift form of justice....

If your toes are near enough to the fire to get burnt, then you were TOOOOO CLOSE....

Its attitudes just like that that make me leary of our justice system. Please oh please tell me you're not a cop, or in anyway affiliated with the justice system!! Better yet, tell that to the Duke lacrosse team members who were staring at 10-20 years in the slammer. Had they been poor, unable to afford a top lawyer, or the case had not garnered such publicity, those kids would be sleeping with someone besides their girlfriends about now. We don't have room for Judge Roy Bean anymore.

road kill
08-22-2010, 08:14 AM
Its attitudes just like that that make me leary of our justice system. Please oh please tell me you're not a cop, or in anyway affiliated with the justice system!! Better yet, tell that to the Duke lacrosse team members who were staring at 10-20 years in the slammer. Had they been poor, unable to afford a top lawyer, or the case had not garnered such publicity, those kids would be sleeping with someone besides their girlfriends about now. We don't have room for Judge Roy Bean anymore.

WTH does this have to do with Saudi Arabia's Judicial syatem?

Or the OP???

You make a lot of ASSumptions.



RK

dnf777
08-22-2010, 09:23 AM
WTH does this have to do with Saudi Arabia's Judicial syatem?

Or the OP???

You make a lot of ASSumptions.



RK

I was responding to norcal's comment. Sorry I broke your forum etiquette...I'm just a real maverick I guess.

The Duke reference was regarding the false accusations of innocent people, to illustrate that it can and does happen in the US.

Anything else I need to explain?