Thanks for the good discussion on this. I got sent on the road this week which adds 4 hours to my day so my time for contributions has been minimal.
I completely agree that it shouldn't be an either or issue. I only raised the (poorly worded) quesiton as to try and figure out which type of issue would be the most likely to decrease the level of our outdoors pursuits as we have them today.
In regards to Henry's comments, I think some "sportsman's" orgs are working towards crossing over. I was really pleased to see Morgan Freeman do his plug for DU. I also think the Rocky Mountain Elk foundation works hard on its mainstream image. Cooperation is key and I agree the moderates in both groups have very similiar goals.