OK I guess I should have said no one who runs Field Trials in America or Canada uses an Acme Spaniel whistle. Those that do would have no chance in hell of being competitive. None.
"Darla" AFC Candlewoods Lil Smokin Tequila (fondly remembered)
"Smoke" Smokin Auggies Menace, QAA
"Simba" Humewood Simba
Well, this has been enlightening to say the least. The USA trial videos are sure showing off handling over objectives. The dogs are snappy and amazingly well trained. ...but then for practicality's sake it seems a bit obnoxious. So much whistle and stop... I guess I'll get flamed for even saying that but its just an initial impression. Coming from my birddog side... a great birddog makes it look easy and like they could do it with or without a handler regardless. Probably skews my views. Still the training side intrigues me... entices even...
BriarField Kennels, Dunlap TN
Miss Mabel Marshdog CGC, TDI certified, canine blood donor (Lab)
Int'l Ch Snips Tennessee Jed SH, NAVHDA NA pz 1(GSP)
Int'l Ch Briarfields Off We Go (GSP)
CH Burrdee Q Anns Lace JH (GSP)
What seems obnoxious can also be absolute beauty. Watching a dog/handler team smash a challenging All Age Blind is very much like the beauty of a perfect Tee Shot on the golf course.
All of these dog games look awkward and funny to the casual observer who is used to a different game or a different breed, or a different land.
It's all good.
I highly doubt Polmais needs to be taught how to get a crisp sit and a reliable sit during stimulating circumstances. I think he has been very successful at that. Seems to me, he wants to hear how you guys go about doing it or how you would go about doing it without the use of an ecollar. This reminds me of Blimps recent thread asking a very similar question and there never was a good answer.
But I'm sure he will correct me if I'm wrong.
Maybe Polmaise will highly doubt it as well. If that's the case, I'm not sure I have a whole lot more effort to put into this one.
I see some folks who seem to be constantly searching for that magic program or that magic process. Back when I was on the contest calling circuit, we called then the guys that were constantly searching for the "magic flute". I'm NOT referencing Polmaise here. I am saying though that for those who seem to be constantly searching, sometimes it is pretty effective to grab ahold of stuff from which some folks have already made quite a bit of hay.
Each time I've gone to EU, I've found that if they cross pollenated with a bit more of the NA FT stuff in their game, they'd likely up their game and start setting some new standards.