First, I heartily agree that the show labs bear little resemblance to what I know as a lab. But.......my sister in law called me this morning to ask my advice regarding a lab pup. She had a "show" type lab that died last fall, and she is considering getting another. I think in her case it is far better that she stick with the same type as I do not believe they could handle a f/t bred dog like mine, (sometimes I wonder if I can!
)So in some ways its ok that there are really two types of dog. I think too many times our type of labs end up in rescue because people are not prepared to raise and train them properly. So there is a place in the average family for those tubby wonders, they all appear to be quite calm and low key. So keep em around!