ding ding ding christinaA wins the prize! Dorado is the other version. As a fisherman my self and with mounds of Mahi in the Freezer It doesnt sound like you got Mahi to me. Also I am sorry you had to eat store bought Mahi. Mine isnt allways same day fresh but for the most part I wached it come out of the water! Almost as much fun as the dog business!