RetrieverTraining.Net - the RTF banner
1 - 14 of 14 Posts

Roger Perry

· Banned
Joined
·
3,611 Posts
Discussion starter · #1 · (Edited)
Very Interesting Jan. 2008 RFTN Judges Corner

Ok, heres the senerio ---- An Amateur 1st series was a double with an honor. The long retired mark was a dead bird thrown under the arc of the flyer. The long mark was about 300 yards from the line. The flyer was about 65 yards from the line and thrown left to right. The test dog completes the test and honors on lead. The first running dog gets a no bird on the flyer. The second running dog comes to the line, handler signals for the birds, the first bird is down and when the flyer is shot it is wounded, not dead, and was walking around quacking in open ground (no cover). The judges, for at least 10 seconds do not call a no bird nor do they call the dogs number for the dog to be sent. The gunners start walking towards the duck and the dog breaks and picks up the live duck. One of the judges told the handler to put his dog on lead and honor.

Does this seniaro sound familiar? How do you think a guest judge answered this question?
 
I think the judges made a mistake. If they cannot decide in 10 seconds if it's a no bird, or to send the dog, the dog should wait three and be given a rerun.
I'll bet the judges had not decided or discussed a flyer that was crippled and walking around in plain view. Sounds like the dog was steady to both birds of the test, and only broke when the gunners went for the walk around.
The dog should not be on lead IMHO. Judges error.
 
Sorry for the dumb question...I know what RFTN is, and I know what RTF is (this site), but what does the acronym RTFN mean? I see it here and on other sites.
 
Discussion starter · #5 · (Edited)
RFTN = Retriever Field Trial News. You can view the Judges Corner (Hosted by Charlie and Yvonne Hays and What's The Score (hosted by Keith Grfiffith) on the Working Retriever web site. Anyone else get their "RFTN" yet?
 
Discussion starter · #8 · (Edited)
If I'm not mistaken wasn't this one of the scenaries Ted posted about a month or so ago?

/Paul
Actually it was a thread I started a few days ago with a little different scenerio. The thread involved an Honor dog and a fly away with a lot of shots fired . Ted did answer the question a couple of times.

I must have been psychotic ---- er --- psychic.
 
Actually it was a thread I started a few days ago with a little different scenerio. The thread involved an Honor dog and a fly away with a lot of shots fired . Ted did answer the question a couple of times.

I must have been psychotic ---- er --- psychic.
Oh I just remember a thread on it.

/Paul
 
RFTN = Retriever Field Trial News. You can view the Judges Corner (Hosted by Charlie and Yvonne Hays and What's The Score (hosted by Keith Grfiffith) on the Working Retriever web site.
Where? I just looked and could not find it.
 
While I sympathize with the honor dog owner, he IS under judgement till he is behind the judges and the holding blind.
He will be asked to honor the next running dog with his dog on lead.:(
Sue
 
Discussion starter · #14 ·
While I sympathize with the honor dog owner, he IS under judgement till he is behind the judges and the holding blind.
He will be asked to honor the next running dog with his dog on lead.:(
Sue
In this post, The test dog was honoring on lead and it was the running that broke after a 10 second delay by the judges not calling a no bird or the dogs number.
 
1 - 14 of 14 Posts