Evan
I tend to disagree and I believe in other ways which are not contradicting
does carry merrit.
In young dogs handling starts off with teaching a dog to change direction
As the training evolves it becomes a form of communication.,,,not merly left or right angles but how much or what factor to pursue.,,,,,,,does the dog parallel the shore line or angle up on it. Thats communication which is developed in my mind not a "lucky cast".
An over cast off a point doesn't nessessarily mean get off the point and scallop back. It can mean WHAT THE #$%^ ARE YOU DOING THERE,,get your arse out of there. Pycologically they totally different
Communication not casting.
These behaviors are taught using drills. and they are checked using cold blinds
Now I do run some cold blinds ,,,,but probably less than most people. But I also use them to test where I am at. And if a problem arises I use an appropriate drill to rectify it.
When a dog looks out on a blind many of them are checking out the factors and are already indicating weather they will attack them or avoid them. Especially the up close ones So I think they should be taught how to negotiate them. I use drills for that.
But yes they will have to do it cold espescially at a test. But in there mind its a drill . By this ,,over that,through this.
So the proper cast will communicate the proper response which for a seasoned dog is more about the communication where to go not so much the cast itself.
If a dog is a little fat as he is swimming down a shore line at 2 or 3 hundred yards and you cast him into the shore line,,,,,,does he move closer to the shore line or does he angle up on it.
I never teach that with cold blinds. They better do it up close before you can ask them to do it at a long distance away.
They better be doing that with drills real well before I do it at 300 yards.
I have a dog here that won an open at 38 months and had probably run a small hand full of cold blinds prior to that.
So I think that method or approach is legitimate if practiced the right way. ,,,,, . As long as training principles are not broken and the phycological
conditioning that takes place is not contradicted by other methods taught in early stages of deveopment.,,,,,then I think your good to go.
Pete