I don't know how to break those quotes up like you did Sharon, so I'll do it this way without misquoting anything.
Sharon writes: Much as I'm tempted (and I was, for about half a second), I'm going to pass on the FF challenge. I much prefer taking my time and doing things slowly, using a collar to reinforce rather than teach.
Fred: If you change your mind on the challenge, it will still be available. I have no problem with that. I just don't think it's fair to make blanket comparison statements if you haven't seen it done by people that do it very successfully at both ends. Is it fair for me to pick one of you people that 'claims' they are doing what Lardy does, and maybe they've been doing for a week. It's not fair for me to say "I just saw the Lardy system and it's not very impressive." I'd go hang around Lardy for awhile, and then take everything everyone else says with a grain of salt. Who have you seen that teaches with a collar?
Sharon: And I found your insults to Evan to be pretty arrogant, by the way.
Fred: Obviously, you didn't have a problem with the jab at me, but that's o.k. I thought I'd just reclarify for the record.

I'm not arrogant, when I put something up like that, I'm very confident about it.
Sharon: How would you know how good someone is with a collar?
Fred: I have eyes. I just know, I watch everything. He's a good trainer, but no way does he want to get in the same arena with me and FF. Ferrari, and model T. Very confident of that, and I'll back it up. Now, before you start twisting it all around into all kinds of advanced retriever stuff, and this and that. My comment was directed at FF. Not only will it be 5 times faster at least, but it will be more thorough also. I'll throw that in as well.
Sharon: Have you stood next to him and watched? So far, you haven't shown us how good you are with it either...it's all smoke and mirrors. Just because what you do is different and relies on an e-collar doesn't make it automatically superior.
Fred: I don't need to stand next to him, I know what I know, and I see what I see. If it's all smoke and mirrors, then you take me up on it. Your welcome to make a fool out of me. You know what you know also. You've already given away your hand in that you don't teach.......you don't have a prayer. Not arrogant, just confident. Smoke and mirrors? Boy am I gonna look stupid then, aren't I?
Sharon: Your offer reminds me of the popular, famous natural horsemanship gurus who rush through colt starting in a few hours and get lots of oohs and ahhs from the uninitiated...they wow the crowd...but come Monday, somebody still has to actually train that colt. I have no doubt at all that you could have an audience in the palm of your hand...but that's not where the proof lies.
Fred: Then what's the problem? You can take a kitty up and get 20 bucks from everyone, and I'll match it. Winner take all. I don't know what to say, cause you keep taking potshots, but not backing it up. I'm the one seeing smoke and mirrors. Oh, only one other prequisite to make it official. I know you have a lot of retriever titles, so you have to take the ribbons, and place them next to the dog during your process.

After all, you can't know anything unless you have a bunch of retriever titles, so we'll have something to look back on. Who knows, the dog may look at them and could just rush to the finish line. You will need all the outside forces you can muster.
Sharon: Ain't nobody gonna do any oohing and ahhing over watching me FF a dog...it's a slow process without any showboating involved, and I have no desire to rush it.
Fred: Great, take your time. I already know that. If there was a better way, you'd be doing it. You just don't know what you don't know. I'll do my three days, and we'll video. I'll go home and wait for you to do your day, week, month, or year, you video the segments. Take your time, cause it wouldn't be a 'fair' evaluation of your program if you rushed it, and it's not someone else's 'perception' of your program. It's your program with you doing it. That's fair. Time isn't important. If you take longer and it's a better job, that's all that counts. If the dog's screaming the whole time and you don't care, well then your just limited to doing it behind closed doors. I ain't tying him up, and I'm not earpinching, and I only need a chair. Obviously, I have to get him picking it up off the ground, and if I get the luxury that you guys have in throwing away all the crap and only taking the good stuff, I'll take him wayyyyyyyyyy farther and it will be a total landslide.
Sharon: Carr/Lardy is a method...a plan, if you will, with a set of building blocks for each skill set that is a logical progression....just because someone is trying to follow that method doesn't mean they instantly turn into Rex Carr or Mike Lardy. It's the innate skill of the individual doing the training and handling that makes or breaks a method.
Fred: Yep, sounds like you know it well. Should be a much easier time for you since you know it, and I'm not going up against someone that doesn't have a clue. I believe Evan knows it as well. You can bring him too, and we can take the better of the two of you against me. No problem, whatever you want to do. I'll have him collar conditioned as well, just to make it easier on you. O.K., so now I have to collar condition, FF, and you and Evan have a bunch of retriever ribbons at the dogs feet to make it more intimidating for me. I don't have a prayer.
Sharon: How about, instead of showboating, you simply explain your method for FF? How does it work, start to finish? How is the collar used? How does it work on a dog with zero desire to retrieve/no prey drive?
Fred: I will make you one promise. After you see this, you will completely understand why it couldn't be explained, and I will point that out a long the way. I promise. You don't know what you don't know.
Sharon: I'm dead serious....I'd love to know, and if you can show me a better way, I'm all over it.
Fred: I'll come out and show you, I need a good dog that knows nothing. I can do a ****ty dog as well, but you won't have any need for that.
Sharon: I'm here, waiting....teach me.
Fred: I need three days, you pay for airfare and room. You have to show me your retrieve as well, I already know what I'm gonna kind of see, but I need to make you accountable in fairness. You've talked an awful big game for this be all end all program that you've got going on over there, so I need to see. I want a comparison in person.[/quote]